Skip to main content

What’s Wrong with the Presidential Debates – How to Fix Them

The fundamental problem is that there is a pretense of moderator neutrality while at least one side thinks the moderator is biased or incompetent. When there is a presumption of unfairness by the moderator whether caused by bias or incompetence, there is no stability with respect to the rules being observed. The person who feels disadvantaged will attempt to resolve the injustice inflicted on him by responding in self defense whether strictly following the rules or not. The other person will then be doing the same thing.

Chris Wallace was primarily responsible for the problems of the first presidential debate of the 2020 election. His questions were asked from the perspective of the Biden campaign rather than open ended. Chris Wallace often challenged President Trump, but rarely called out Biden for lies or evasions.

One problem is having a supposedly neutral moderator in the first place. It is unlikely both parties will trust a moderator to be neutral. The questions should be posed to the candidates by one another rather than by a moderator. Simply deciding the questions to ask will introduce bias. Also, there should be a timer similar to a chess timer linked to the microphones and cameras to give the two candidates equal time. When a candidate was finished speaking or reached a fixed time limit agreed to (day two or three minutes), he would turn the time over to the other candidate. The timer would be automatically triggered at the time limit. If one candidate ran out of time, then the other candidate would get his remaining time to finish talking and conclude the debate for up to 5 minutes or some other agreed limit.

This would allow the candidates to get equal time, ask relevant questions, and speak without interruption or the other candidate making faces while the other talks.

Eliminating the moderator would allow serious questions to be asked and candidates could be judged for the questions they asked as well as their answers. A moderator just gets in the way in pursuit of his own agenda rather than letting the public get a better understanding of the candidates.

There should also be a check of both candidates for communication devices to ensure neither candidate is cheating.

To keep the candidates honest, the debate commission web site should link to each of the campaign web sites. Those sites would show fact checking done by the campaigns disputing the other candidate and supporting their own candidate.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

TSA Employees Finally Getting Paid What They are Worth

The government shutdown has caused TSA employees to not get paid. Considering that they provide negative overall value to the nation and travelers, they are still technically getting over paid. However, getting them to pay travelers is not feasible. They generally provide very little protection for the inconvenience and humiliation they inflict on travelers. The real security in an airplane cabin is a secure cockpit and passengers who will fight hijackers to the death now that we know what they are up to. I'm also still waiting to hear a good explanation of why banning pocket knives from aircraft and other great TSA ideas enhances our security. Basic TSA-Pre screening without those ridiculously expensive scanners (also known as what was done before 9-11) is also perfectly adequate. The Huffington Post has a whiny article about the TSA employees not getting paid. Of course, all government employees including those not actually showing up for work will get back pay once the approp
Post a Comment
Read more

Arizonans are Taxed Enough

This is a response to this opinion piece in the Jewish News of Greater Phoenix. In his opinion piece, “Taxes Far More Than Necessary Evil,” Rabbi Strauss demonstrates why he should stick to his “day job” as a synagogue spiritual leader. His writing on both Halacha and tax issues is filled with misinformation and erroneous reasoning. Rabbi Strauss cites the tax to support the Mishkan as proof that taxes have been a legitimate part of Jewish life since we left Egypt. Of course, that was a poll tax that was imposed on every adult male regardless of income or wealth. He goes on to immediately say that Jewish sources tell us that there is an obligation to provide universal education and health care for the poor – using taxes to finance it. His Jewish sources must be liberal Jewish editorial writers since the Torah requires only supporting Torah education rather than general education – and only in cases where the family is unable to afford it. According to our tradition, parents have
Post a Comment
Read more

Turn the Tables on Biden in the Debate

 In the Presidential Debate tonight, President Trump should turn the tables on Joe Biden.  Do you remember the ridiculous question in the first debate asking Trump to denounce White Supremacy groups as if there were any doubt on his position? Trump has denounced them consistently and clearly. In fact, the question should have been directed at Joe Biden who has worked closely with KKK leader Robert Byrd in the Senate as well as other White Supremacists and regularly uses bigoted language. Trump, when he inevitably gets a question like that should not even answer it. Instead, he should point to his consistent record against racism, admonish the moderator for being sloppy by not referencing those statements, and tell the moderator he should be asking Joe Biden that question. Mention Joe Biden’s friendships with KKK and other racist senators. Reference Joe’s language such as “whether you are poor or white” and “there is little diversity in the black community” with respect to culture and
Post a Comment
Read more